The cranes went first, in sections, on a barge, over the course of a fortnight that people here still describe by the weather. Then the customs office. Then, more slowly and with less ceremony, the chandlers, the two cafés that opened at four in the morning, and the bus route that had existed solely to bring the night shift in from the estate.

A port town without a port is not a ruin. That is the first correction the residents make, usually within a minute of meeting you. It is a town with a very large empty asset in the middle of it, excellent road access, and a housing stock built for a workforce that no longer commutes anywhere.

What the water is worth

The argument in the town concerns the quay itself. One proposal treats the waterfront as real estate: apartments, a hotel, a promenade, the familiar sequence. Another, pushed by a group of former terminal engineers, argues that the deep-water berth is a strategic asset that took a century to build and forty years to pay for, and that filling it with balconies would be an act of civic amnesia.

You cannot dig another one. That is the whole argument. There is no second deep-water berth, and there never will be.

A retired terminal engineer

Both sides can point to towns down the coast that took the other path and regret it. This is the difficulty with the comparison: the counterfactual is always available, and it is always somebody else's disappointment.

Rows of low terraced houses on a hill above a harbour, washing lines strung between them.
Housing built for shift workers, now the cheapest coastal property within two hours of the city.Photography for Vision Magazine

The slow arrivals

Meanwhile something else is happening, unplanned and largely undocumented. The cheap housing has drawn a steady trickle of people who work remotely and wanted a sea view, and a smaller number who came for the workshop space in the disused warehouses. Neither group is large. Together they have kept the primary school open, which the council's own projections said would close in 2024.

Nobody in the town describes this as regeneration, a word that arrives here attached to consultants. They describe it as people moving in, which is both less impressive and considerably more durable.

On the last evening the tide is out and the empty berth is visible down to the silt — a rectangle of engineered depth in an otherwise shallow bay, waiting for a decision that will not be made this year, and possibly not this decade.